Beyond Organic. Beyond Delicious.

Organic Whole Milk Plain Cream Top Yogurt

Kalona SuperNatural™ Cream Top Yogurt looks different because it is different! To achieve the simplicity of a European style yogurt, we avoid using stabilizers or thickeners that are common in most other yogurts. The result is a clean tasting, cream top yogurt with a marbled texture, similar to homemade yogurt! Like all of our products, we start with organic, grass-fed, non-homogenized milk from small, sustainable Midwest family farms.

We keep things simple. So you can too.


Our whole milk plain cream top yogurt is made the old-fashioned way. We batch-pasteurize our yogurt at low temperatures, fill the cups, and place it in a warm room to set. Because we choose to “cup set” our yogurt, consumers can expect to see some variance from batch to batch. We are proud to offer this healthy, probiotic treat in its most natural state possible.

If it seems easy, it’s because it is.

Watch Video

Additional information


24 oz


Plain, Vanilla


Organic Cultured Grade A Milk, Organic Skim Milk, Organic Cream.

Live Action Cultures

s. thermophilus, l. acidophilus, bifidus, l. bulgaris


  1. M. Larson – Cedar Rapids, IA

    My wife and I would like to thank you for this great tasting yogurt! Weve searched high and low to find an alternative to the major brands, all of which seem to be filled with high fructose corn syrup, artificial colors and flavors, and who knows what else. We were pleased to discover such a wonderful alternative, produced > locally—another plus as far as were concerned. Weve tried several flavors of your lowfat variety now and enjoy them all.

  2. Jeff A.

    After getting back from an extended stay in France, I started searching for an American yogurt that didn’t taste like Jello pudding. About a year back, I discovered your yogurt and have been a pretty loyal customer ever since. What I found appealing in your product was that it was less sweet, and thinner in texture than most American yogurts, i.e. more like what I found in France.

  3. K. Earnest – Coralville, Iowa

    You have a great product. I am so happy to have found a natural-tasting yogurt without all the sugar and without the ARTIFICIAL sweetening! Great job!

  4. Fran

    I have never written a food company before, but I just have to tell you that I LOVE the Kalona SuperNatural organic yogurt!

    Im a yogurt and cheese snob and havent found anything I like since experiencing great products while living in France. This yogurt… is delicious and has a great texture.

    Thanks for producing such a wonderful product. Delicious, healthy, and hormone-free!

  5. Julie

    I wanted to write to let you know how appreciative I am to have found your yogurt (at Hyvee grocery store, Rochester, MN). Many years ago I lived in Japan and ate fresh, natural yogurt for breakfast each morning. I have been unable to find anything comparable until now. In fact, I had stopped eating yogurt altogether to avoid the high sugar content and artificial flavors. Thank you for producing a wonderfully tasty and natural yogurt.

  6. Glynnis – Woodstock Illinois

    I just wanted to tell you that your plain yogurt is the best I’ve ever had. I love yogurt but had just about given on the commercial stuff because it is full of sugar or worse aspartame or sucralose. But your yogurt is so good I drive out of my way to get it. Just thought you should know.

  7. Emily

    I don’t know what they do to make the yogurt, but it is like nothing else on the market… It’s as close in flavor to raw dairy yogurt as you can get, plus it comes in a whole milk variety with cream line…which is maybe the best thing on earth.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Contact Us



Carry Our Products

5195 Farmers Ave SW
Kalona, IA 52247

© Kalona SuperNatural ™
Blog (RSS)

Join Our Herd

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter and save $1 off your next organic milk purchase!

Store Locator

Search for Kalona SuperNatural products near you!
Store Locator

Follow Us


Kalona SuperNatural™

The Kalona SuperNatural™ brand is owned and distributed by Kalona Organics, an Open Gates Group company.
Privacy Policy